---
title: Why Strong Results are No Longer Enough in Modern Peer Review
description: Reviewers now expect clear, reproducible methods. Learn how transparency and method detail shape modern peer review outcomes.
image: https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/Why%20Strong%20Results%20Are%20No%20Longer%20Enough%20in%20Modern%20Peer%20Review.png
---

[JoVE](https://www.jove.com/)

[Faculty Resource Center](https://app.jove.com/playlist/library/all)

Research![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Blog-design-template-2022/Jove_july2k22_test/template/icons/chevron-down-regular.svg)

[Behavior](https://www.jove.com/research/behavior) [Biochemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/biochemistry) [Bioengineering](https://www.jove.com/research/bioengineering) [Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/biology) [Cancer Research](https://www.jove.com/research/cancer-research) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/chemistry) [Developmental Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/developmental-biology) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/research/engineering) [Environment](https://www.jove.com/research/environment) [Genetics](https://www.jove.com/research/genetics) [Immunology and Infection](https://www.jove.com/research/immunology-infection) [Medicine](https://www.jove.com/research/medicine) [Neuroscience](https://www.jove.com/research/neuroscience)

---

[JoVE **Journal**](https://www.jove.com/journal) [JoVE **Encyclopedia of Experiments**New](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)

Education![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Blog-design-template-2022/Jove_july2k22_test/template/icons/chevron-down-regular.svg)

[Biology](https://www.jove.com/education/biology) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/education/chemistry) [Statistics](https://www.jove.com/science-education/corestats) [Environmental Sciences](https://www.jove.com/education/envirosci) [Physics](https://www.jove.com/education/physics) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/education/eng) [Psychology](https://www.jove.com/education/psychology) [Clinical Skills](https://www.jove.com/education/clinicskills)

---

[JoVE **Core**](https://www.jove.com/education/core) [JoVE **Science Education**](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library) [JoVE **Lab Manual**](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual) [JoVE **Book**NEW](https://www.jove.com/video-textbook)

---

[JoVE QuizBeta](https://www.jove.com/quiz) [Videos Mapped to Your Course](https://www.jove.com/syllabus-mapping) 

[Authors](https://www.jove.com/authors/overview) [Librarians](https://www.jove.com/librarians/overview) [About](https://www.jove.com/about) [Blog](https://blog.jove.com)

[Contact Us](https://www.jove.com/about/contact)

Research

[JoVE **Journal**](https://www.jove.com/journal) [JoVE **Encyclopedia of Experiments**New](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)

Education

[JoVE **Core**](https://www.jove.com/education/core) [JoVE **Science Education**](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library) [JoVE **Lab Manual**](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual) [JoVE **Book**NEW](https://www.jove.com/video-textbook)

[![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Blog-design-template-2022/Jove_july2k22_test/template/icons/jove-logo-black.svg)](https://www.jove.com/) Close

Research

[Behavior](https://www.jove.com/research/behavior) [Biochemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/biochemistry) [Bioengineering](https://www.jove.com/research/bioengineering) [Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/biology) [Cancer Research](https://www.jove.com/research/cancer-research) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/chemistry) [Developmental Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/developmental-biology) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/research/engineering) [Environment](https://www.jove.com/research/environment) [Genetics](https://www.jove.com/research/genetics) [Immunology and Infection](https://www.jove.com/research/immunology-infection) [Medicine](https://www.jove.com/research/medicine) [Neuroscience](https://www.jove.com/research/neuroscience) Products [JoVE Journal](https://www.jove.com/journal) [JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)

Education

[Biology](https://www.jove.com/education/biology) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/education/chemistry) [Statistics](https://www.jove.com/science-education/corestats) [Environmental Sciences](https://www.jove.com/education/envirosci) [Physics](https://www.jove.com/education/physics) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/education/eng) [Psychology](https://www.jove.com/education/psychology) [Clinical Skills](https://www.jove.com/education/clinicskills) Products [JoVE Core](https://www.jove.com/education/core) [JoVE Science Education](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library) [JoVE Lab Manual](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual) [JoVE **Book**NEW](https://www.jove.com/video-textbook) [JoVE QuizBeta](https://www.jove.com/quiz) [Videos Mapped to Your Course](https://www.jove.com/syllabus-mapping)

[Submit Feedback](https://www.jove.com/about/contact) [About Us](https://www.jove.com/about/)

[JoVE](https://www.jove.com/)

[JoVE](https://www.jove.com/)

[Faculty Resource Center](https://www.jove.com/facultyresources)

Research![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Blog-design-template-2022/Jove_july2k22_test/template/icons/chevron-down-regular.svg)

[Behavior](https://www.jove.com/research/behavior) [Biochemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/biochemistry) [Bioengineering](https://www.jove.com/research/bioengineering) [Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/biology) [Cancer Research](https://www.jove.com/research/cancer-research) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/chemistry) [Developmental Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/developmental-biology) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/research/engineering) [Environment](https://www.jove.com/research/environment) [Genetics](https://www.jove.com/research/genetics) [Immunology and Infection](https://www.jove.com/research/immunology-infection) [Medicine](https://www.jove.com/research/medicine) [Neuroscience](https://www.jove.com/research/neuroscience)

---

[JoVE **Journal**](https://www.jove.com/journal) [JoVE **Encyclopedia of Experiments**New](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)

Education![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Blog-design-template-2022/Jove_july2k22_test/template/icons/chevron-down-regular.svg)

[Biology](https://www.jove.com/education/biology) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/education/chemistry) [Statistics](https://www.jove.com/science-education/corestats) [Environmental Sciences](https://www.jove.com/education/envirosci) [Physics](https://www.jove.com/education/physics) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/education/eng) [Psychology](https://www.jove.com/education/psychology) [Clinical Skills](https://www.jove.com/education/clinicskills)

---

[JoVE **Core**](https://www.jove.com/education/core) [JoVE **Science Education**](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library) [JoVE **Lab Manual**](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual) [JoVE **Book**NEW](https://www.jove.com/video-textbook)

---

[JoVE QuizBeta](https://www.jove.com/quiz) [Videos Mapped to Your Course](https://www.jove.com/syllabus-mapping) 

[Authors](https://www.jove.com/authors/overview) [Librarians](https://www.jove.com/librarians/overview) [About](https://www.jove.com/about)

[Sign In](https://www.jove.com/account/signin)

[Sign In](https://www.jove.com/account/signin) [Contact Us](https://www.jove.com/about/contact)

Research

[JoVE **Journal**](https://www.jove.com/journal) [JoVE **Encyclopedia of Experiments**New](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)

Education

[JoVE **Core**](https://www.jove.com/education/core) [JoVE **Science Education**](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library) [JoVE **Lab Manual**](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual) [JoVE **Book**NEW](https://www.jove.com/video-textbook)

[![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Blog-design-template-2022/Jove_july2k22_test/template/icons/jove-logo-black.svg)](https://www.jove.com/) Close

Research

[Behavior](https://www.jove.com/research/behavior) [Biochemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/biochemistry) [Bioengineering](https://www.jove.com/research/bioengineering) [Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/biology) [Cancer Research](https://www.jove.com/research/cancer-research) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/research/chemistry) [Developmental Biology](https://www.jove.com/research/developmental-biology) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/research/engineering) [Environment](https://www.jove.com/research/environment) [Genetics](https://www.jove.com/research/genetics) [Immunology and Infection](https://www.jove.com/research/immunology-infection) [Medicine](https://www.jove.com/research/medicine) [Neuroscience](https://www.jove.com/research/neuroscience) Products [JoVE Journal](https://www.jove.com/journal) [JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)

Education

[Biology](https://www.jove.com/education/biology) [Chemistry](https://www.jove.com/education/chemistry) [Statistics](https://www.jove.com/science-education/corestats) [Environmental Sciences](https://www.jove.com/education/envirosci) [Physics](https://www.jove.com/education/physics) [Engineering](https://www.jove.com/education/eng) [Psychology](https://www.jove.com/education/psychology) [Clinical Skills](https://www.jove.com/education/clinicskills) Products [JoVE Core](https://www.jove.com/education/core) [JoVE Science Education](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library) [JoVE Lab Manual](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual) [JoVE **Book**NEW](https://www.jove.com/video-textbook) [JoVE QuizBeta](https://www.jove.com/quiz) [Videos Mapped to Your Course](https://www.jove.com/syllabus-mapping)

[Blog](https://blog.jove.com) [Submit Feedback](https://www.jove.com/about/contact) [About Us](https://www.jove.com/about/)

[← Previous Page](https://blog.jove.com)

[← Previous Page](https://blog.jove.com)

![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/Why%20Strong%20Results%20Are%20No%20Longer%20Enough%20in%20Modern%20Peer%20Review.png) 

![...](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/Why%20Strong%20Results%20Are%20No%20Longer%20Enough%20in%20Modern%20Peer%20Review.png)

 research

# Why Strong Results are No Longer Enough in Modern Peer Review

 Ellen Ovenden, MSc | Mar 30, 2026

[![](https://cloudfront.jove.com/img/icons/linkedin-in-brands_white.svg)](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://blog.jove.com/strong-results-are-no-longer-enough-peer-review-2026) [![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/Imported%20images/twitter-white.png)](http://www.twitter.com/share?url=https://blog.jove.com/strong-results-are-no-longer-enough-peer-review-2026) [![](https://cloudfront.jove.com/img/icons/facebook-square-brands_white.svg)](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://blog.jove.com/strong-results-are-no-longer-enough-peer-review-2026)

 Ellen Ovenden, MSc | Mar 30 2026

[![](https://cloudfront.jove.com/img/icons/linkedin-in-brands_white.svg)](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https://blog.jove.com/strong-results-are-no-longer-enough-peer-review-2026) [![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/Imported%20images/twitter-white.png)](http://www.twitter.com/share?url=https://blog.jove.com/strong-results-are-no-longer-enough-peer-review-2026) [![](https://cloudfront.jove.com/img/icons/facebook-square-brands_white.svg)](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://blog.jove.com/strong-results-are-no-longer-enough-peer-review-2026)

Today, a promising result is only part of what reviewers are looking for. They also want to know whether the work is transparent enough to evaluate and clear enough to reproduce.

In a 2025 study, journals without a code-sharing policy showed **8.1 times lower reproducibility potential** than otherwise similar journals with code-sharing requirements.1 This helps explain why reviewers now look more closely at method detail, reporting rigor, and how easily a study can be checked and reused.

---

### What Reviewers Look For Now

- ▪️ **Method detail that can actually be followed**  
  Reviewers expect enough detail to understand experimental setup, not just what the outcome was.
- ▪️ **Reporting that reduces guesswork**  
  Missing parameters, compressed workflows, and unclear setup descriptions are more likely to be flagged because they make evaluation harder.1
- ▪️ **A record that supports verification**  
  Expectations differ by field, but reviewers increasingly expect enough transparency around data, code, and analysis choices to see how the conclusions were reached.2
- ▪️ **Clarity across disciplinary boundaries**  
  If the work spans multiple fields, it has to be understandable to reviewers who may not share the same technical assumptions.3

For complex methods, visual formats **make key procedural details easier to assess**. A written methods section can describe sequence, materials, and parameters, but a video shows what successful execution actually looks like: setup, timing, positioning, hand movements, and **small steps that are easy to interpret differently** in prose alone.

- ![JaquelineTCGIF1-ezgif.com-optimize-1](https://blog.jove.com/hs-fs/hubfs/JaquelineTCGIF1-ezgif.com-optimize-1.gif?width=600&height=337&name=JaquelineTCGIF1-ezgif.com-optimize-1.gif)
- ![MethodsCollection (1)-1](https://blog.jove.com/hs-fs/hubfs/MethodsCollection%20(1)-1.gif?width=700&height=379&name=MethodsCollection%20(1)-1.gif)
- ![Suhyun TC GIF (2)-1](https://blog.jove.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Suhyun%20TC%20GIF%20(2)-1.gif?width=800&height=434&name=Suhyun%20TC%20GIF%20(2)-1.gif)

---

### How Clearer Method Communication Helps

- ▪️ **Helps reviewers inspect the work more confidently**  
  When a method is easier to follow, evaluation becomes more grounded and less dependent on inference.
- ▪️ **Helps future users repeat the work more consistently**  
  Clearer method communication supports reproducibility after publication, not just readability during review.
- ▪️ **Strengthens research beyond the review stage**  
  Better method clarity can improve reuse, collaboration, and adoption, especially for technically demanding workflows.

Visibility helps a paper reach the right audience, but method clarity helps the work hold up once it gets there. For researchers working with complex protocols, visual publishing can add a **layer of precision that supports both review and reuse**.

---

### The Next Step

As reviewer expectations continue to evolve, it is no longer enough for a method to sound rigorous. It needs to be clear enough to evaluate, reproduce, and build on. For complex protocols, visual communication is becoming an important part of meeting that standard.

### **Learn how visual publication can support clearer method communication and strengthen your next submission.**

[Explore JoVE's Submission Hub](https://info.jove.com/jove-submission-hub-lp-blog?hsLang=en)

1. Sánchez-Tójar, A., Bezine, A., Purgar, M., & Culina, A. (2025). Code-sharing policies are associated with increased reproducibility potential of ecological findings. *Peer Community Journal*, 5, e37. [https://doi.org/10.24072/pcjournal.541](https://doi.org/10.24072/pcjournal.541) 
2. Aczel, B., Barwich, A.-S., Diekman, A. B., et al. (2025). The present and future of peer review: Ideas, interventions, and evidence. *Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(5)*, e2401232121. [https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2401232121](https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2401232121)  
3. Zhang, Y., & Wang, Y. (2024). Understanding delays in publishing interdisciplinary research. Information *Processing & Management, 61(5)*, 103826. [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ipm.2024.103826 ](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ipm.2024.103826) 

---

### Related Posts

- [JoVE](https://www.jove.com/) 
  
    - [Privacy](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)  •   [Terms of Use](https://www.jove.com/about/policies#step-2)  •   [Policies](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)
    - - [Share on Twitter](http://twitter.com/JoVEjournal)
          - [Share on Facebook](http://www.facebook.com/JoVEjournal)
          - [Share on LinkedIn](http://www.linkedin.com/company/jove)
          - [Contact Us](https://www.jove.com/about/contact)
          - [Recommend US](https://www.jove.com/recommend-jove-to-your-librarian)
          - [JoVE NEWSLETTERS](https://www.jove.com/subscribe-to-jove-newsletters)
- ###### RESEARCH
  
    - [JoVE Journal](https://www.jove.com/journal)
    - [Methods Collections](https://www.jove.com/methods-collections)
    - [JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)
    - [Archive](https://www.jove.com/archive)
  
  ###### EDUCATION
  
    - [JoVE Core](https://www.jove.com/education/core)
    - [JoVE Science Education](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library/)
    - [JoVE Lab Manual](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual)
    - [Faculty Resource Center](https://www.jove.com/facultyresources)
- ###### Authors
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/authors/overview)
    - [Publishing Process](https://www.jove.com/authors/publication)
    - [Editorial Board](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-board)
    - [Scope and Policies](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-policies)
    - [Peer Review](https://www.jove.com/authors/peer-review)
    - [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/authors/faq)
    - [Submit](https://www.jove.com/authors/submit)
- ###### Librarians
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/librarians/overview)
    - [Testimonials](https://www.jove.com/librarians/testimonials)
    - [Subscriptions](https://www.jove.com/librarians/subscriptions)
    - [Access](https://www.jove.com/access)
    - [Resources](https://www.jove.com/librarians/resources)
    - [Library Advisory Board](https://www.jove.com/librarians/advisory-board)
    - [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/librarians/faq)
- ###### ABOUT JoVE
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/about)
    - [Leadership](https://www.jove.com/about/leadership/)
    - [Blog](https://blog.jove.com/)

- [JoVE](https://www.jove.com/)
  
    - [Privacy](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)  •  [Terms of Use](https://www.jove.com/about/policies#step-2)  •  [Policies](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)
    - - [Share on Twitter](http://twitter.com/JoVEjournal)
          - [Share on Facebook](http://www.facebook.com/JoVEjournal)
          - [Share on LinkedIn](http://www.linkedin.com/company/jove)
          - Share on Wechat
          - [Contact Us](https://www.jove.com/about/contact)
          - [Recommend US](https://www.jove.com/recommend-jove-to-your-librarian)
          - [JoVE NEWSLETTERS](https://www.jove.com/subscribe-to-jove-newsletters)
- ###### RESEARCH
  
    - [JoVE Journal](https://www.jove.com/journal)
    - [Methods Collections](https://www.jove.com/methods-collections)
    - [JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)
    - [Archive](https://www.jove.com/archive)
  
  ###### EDUCATION
  
    - [JoVE Core](https://www.jove.com/education/core)
    - [JoVE Science Education](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library/)
    - [JoVE Lab Manual](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual)
    - [Faculty Resource Center](https://www.jove.com/facultyresources)
- ###### Authors
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/authors/overview)
    - [Publishing Process](https://www.jove.com/authors/publication)
    - [Editorial Board](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-board)
    - [Scope and Policies](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-policies)
    - [Peer Review](https://www.jove.com/authors/peer-review)
    - [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/authors/faq)
    - [Submit](https://www.jove.com/authors/submit)
  
  ###### Librarians
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/librarians/overview)
    - [Testimonials](https://www.jove.com/librarians/testimonials)
    - [Subscriptions](https://www.jove.com/librarians/subscriptions)
    - [Access](https://www.jove.com/access)
    - [Resources](https://www.jove.com/librarians/resources)
    - [Library Advisory Board](https://www.jove.com/librarians/advisory-board)
    - [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/librarians/faq)
- ###### ABOUT JoVE
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/about)
    - [Leadership](https://www.jove.com/about/leadership/)
    - [Blog](https://blog.jove.com/)

- ###### RESEARCH
  
    - [JoVE Journal](https://www.jove.com/journal)
    - [Methods Collections](https://www.jove.com/methods-collections)
    - [JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments)
    - [Archive](https://www.jove.com/archive)
  
  ###### EDUCATION
  
    - [JoVE Core](https://www.jove.com/education/core)
    - [JoVE Science Education](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library/)
    - [JoVE Lab Manual](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual)
    - [Faculty Resource Center](https://www.jove.com/facultyresources)
  
  ###### Authors
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/authors/overview)
    - [Publishing Process](https://www.jove.com/authors/publication)
    - [Editorial Board](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-board)
    - [Scope and Policies](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-policies)
    - [Peer Review](https://www.jove.com/authors/peer-review)
    - [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/authors/faq)
    - [Submit](https://www.jove.com/authors/submit)
- ###### Librarians
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/librarians/overview)
    - [Testimonials](https://www.jove.com/librarians/testimonials)
    - [Subscriptions](https://www.jove.com/librarians/subscriptions)
    - [Access](https://www.jove.com/access)
    - [Resources](https://www.jove.com/librarians/resources)
    - [Library Advisory Board](https://www.jove.com/librarians/advisory-board)
    - [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/librarians/faq)
  
  ###### ABOUT JoVE
  
    - [Overview](https://www.jove.com/about)
    - [Leadership](https://www.jove.com/about/leadership/)
    - [Blog](https://blog.jove.com/)
  
  [JoVE](https://www.jove.com/)
  
    - [Privacy](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)  •  [Terms of Use](https://www.jove.com/about/policies#step-2)  •  [Policies](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)
    - - [Share on Twitter](http://twitter.com/JoVEjournal)
          - [Share on Facebook](http://www.facebook.com/JoVEjournal)
          - [Share on LinkedIn](http://www.linkedin.com/company/jove)
          - [Contact Us](https://www.jove.com/about/contact)
          - [Recommend US](https://www.jove.com/recommend-jove-to-your-librarian)

###### RESEARCH

[JoVE Journal](https://www.jove.com/journal) [Methods Collections](https://www.jove.com/methods-collections) [JoVE Encyclopedia of Experiments](https://www.jove.com/encyclopedia-of-experiments) [Archive](https://www.jove.com/archive)

---

###### EDUCATION

[JoVE Core](https://www.jove.com/education/core) [JoVE Science Education](https://www.jove.com/science-education-library/) [JoVE Lab Manual](https://www.jove.com/education/lab-manual) [Faculty Resource Center](https://www.jove.com/facultyresources)

---

###### Authors

[Overview](https://www.jove.com/authors/overview) [Publishing Process](https://www.jove.com/authors/publication) [Editorial Board](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-board) [Scope and Policies](https://www.jove.com/authors/editorial-policies) [Peer Review](https://www.jove.com/authors/peer-review) [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/authors/faq) [Submit](https://www.jove.com/authors/submit)

---

###### Librarians

[Overview](https://www.jove.com/librarians/overview) [Testimonials](https://www.jove.com/librarians/testimonials) [Subscriptions](https://www.jove.com/librarians/subscriptions) [Access](https://www.jove.com/access) [Resources](https://www.jove.com/librarians/resources) [Library Advisory Board](https://www.jove.com/librarians/advisory-board) [FAQ](https://www.jove.com/librarians/faq)

---

###### ABOUT JoVE

[Overview](https://www.jove.com/about) [Leadership](https://www.jove.com/about/leadership/) [Blog](https://blog.jove.com/)

---

![](https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Blog-design-template-2022/Jove_july2k22_test/template/icons/jove-logo-white.svg)

- - [Share on Twitter](http://twitter.com/JoVEjournal)
    - [Share on Facebook](http://www.facebook.com/JoVEjournal)
    - [Share on LinkedIn](http://www.linkedin.com/company/jove)

[Contact Us](https://www.jove.com/about/contact)

[Recommend Us](https://www.jove.com/recommend-jove-to-your-librarian)

- [Privacy](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)
- .
- [Terms of Use](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)
- .
- [Policies](https://www.jove.com/about/policies)

---

 Copyright © 2026 MyJoVE Corporation. All rights reserved

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Ellen Ovenden",
    "url" : "https://blog.jove.com/author/ellen-ovenden"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-05-20T18:03:46.202Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-03-30T21:00:32.000Z",
  "headline" : "Why Strong Results are No Longer Enough in Modern Peer Review",
  "image" : [ "https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/Why%20Strong%20Results%20Are%20No%20Longer%20Enough%20in%20Modern%20Peer%20Review.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://blog.jove.com/strong-results-are-no-longer-enough-peer-review-2026",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://blog.jove.com/hubfs/JoVE%20K12%20Logo.png"
    },
    "name" : "MyJoVE Corporation"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "VideoObject",
  "contentUrl" : "https://20267955.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/20267955/video_assets/210739810128/inherited/web_optimized.mp4",
  "dateModified" : "2026-04-09T09:39:36.132Z",
  "duration" : "PT30.741S",
  "height" : 900,
  "name" : "2025 Editorial webinars_SM Banners",
  "thumbnailUrl" : "https://api-na1.hubspot.com/filemanager/api/v3/files/thumbnail-redirect/210739810128?portalId=20267955&size=medium",
  "uploadDate" : "2026-04-09T09:39:36.130Z",
  "width" : 1600
}
```